May 29, 2020   |   by admin

Ihtijaj (Argumentation) [Abu Mansur Ahmad Tabarsi, Saiyyed Amir Husayn Sarkishian] on *FREE* shipping on qualifying offers. In the introduction. Al–Ihtijaj by Allama Abu Mansur Ahmad Tibrisi Vol Uploaded by Syed Naqvi. Islamic Urdu Book. Copyright: Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC). Download. Al-Tabarsi and the Distortion of the Qur’an. Al-Tabarsi mentions in his book al- Ihtijaj (vol. 1 pg. ) while discussing the argument of Amir al-Mu’minin `Ali radiya Llahu `anhu.

Author: Nedal Dushakar
Country: Japan
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: History
Published (Last): 6 November 2015
Pages: 479
PDF File Size: 18.43 Mb
ePub File Size: 20.99 Mb
ISBN: 870-8-63402-442-3
Downloads: 76105
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Yozshuramar

Translator’s Introduction | A Shi’ite Anthology |

Many of great Shi’a scholars, such as al-Shaykh al-Hurr al-‘Amili in Amal al-amilKhwansari in Rawdat al-jannat and al-Khoei in Mu’jam Rijal al-Hadithregarded this book as precious, good and very useful.

Even a zionist can not do that.

Go back to some of my post, to understand that you speaking with brother who is well aware about shia beliefs. Don’t you agree that the absence of a word from the Quran could change the meaning of a verse? The Sources In making the selections ‘Allamah Tabataba’i utilized four works: Muslims hold these to be the most important source of Islamic teachings after the Qur’an. Al-Tabarsi [1] taabrsi in his book al-Ihtijaj vol.

In short, collections of hadith s in Sunni Islam, such as those of al-Bukhari and Muslim, contain only sayings transmitted from and about the Prophet. Others who may feel that the present translation does not do justice to the literary qualities of the text may try their own hand at rendering it into English. The Translations A note needs to be added about the method of translation.

There the author of the article ” Hadith ” is aware that there is some difference between Shi’ism and Sunnism ihtiuaj the question of which hadith s are included, but he thinks that it lies in the fact that the Shi’ite collections accept “only traditions traced through ‘Ali’s family. I have added two words, and the meaning of text changed.


Correct me if I am wrong, but you argue that Tabarsi simply believed that some parts of Quran are yabarsi. Let him reveal to the people of depth the high status and high rank which was experienced by this elite.

Mirza Nuri did indeed write a book attempting to prove that there are verses missing from the Qur’an. What is a ruling of a man who rejects verse from Quran? If Tabarsi as you claim only believed that something been dropped from Quran, he believed in such type of alteration tahrif. All he believed was that some verses are missing like if someone believed the Imams or the Prophet could forget at times.

Now you tell me: Look how harshly Ayatullah Najafabadi was critiqued for his book where he denied ‘Ilm ul-Ghayb of the Imam, yet no one considered him a disbeliever. You shouldn’t be expecting a Salafi-Militant ideology amongst us, where we are just waiting for a slight opportunity to start passing takfir on someone.

The first two works are discussed in Dr. So be patient, O Muhammadas were those of determination among the messengers.

The final category consists of that which is known only to Allah, His Trustees the Imams and those firm in knowledge. What would be ruling on a man, who would compile independent book in order to provide proofs that Ahlalbayt had shortcomings?

I have seen all Shias are in agreement that whoever would accuse Ahlalbayt in deficiency – is kaafir. The book tabarsl well known as “Ihtijaj al-Tabrisi.


al-Tabrasi author of al-Ihtijaj and Tahreef

The book have been translated several times into Persian. Yes, indeed some shia thinkers tried to reject accusation that Noori wrote that book, by changing its heading. And why is just an tabatsi of a verse an issue?

Peace upon the family of Yasin [10]. Edit Edited October 13, by skamran This is not a very solid argument or even a proper comparison.

al-Tabrasi author of al-Ihtijaj and Tahreef

If you are taking his book and understanding something other than what he himself is claiming his belief to be, then you are simply not understanding his work or are on an agenda to misuse his words. I have simply omitted word ” not “, and how dramatically meaning is changed?

The importance the work has possessed since its compilation as the standard reference work for all Shi’ite studies can hardly be overemphasized. There are definite disadvantages to this method, but the necessity for an accurate translation would seem to outweigh them all.

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment. And in volume 10 of his book “adh-Dhariyah”, pageTahrani spoke about this answer of Noori. Jibril descended upon Muhammad sallalahu alaihi wa ali with this verse, in this form: If people and scholars emotionally call out this person for Nasb, then I don’t see this as anything more than name-calling and attacking the person. Or you would accuse him in nasb, which is basically is worse for you than taabarsi